I am not certain where the term “oops” came from, but apparently the term inspired the title of a book, O.O.P.S.: Observing Our Politicians Stumble.
Politico, which has been deconstructing the crashed-and-burned presidential campaign of Gov. Scott Walker, lists seven Walker gaffes:
1. Mazel tov
In December, a letter surfaced where Walker had made an unforced error responding to a Jewish constituent by writing “thank you again and Molotov.” Walker meant Mazel tov.2. The Europe curse
In February, Walker made things tougher for himself when, during a trip to Europe, he refused to answer questions on foreign policy.“I just think for me, commenting on foreign policy, or in this case economic policy, in a country where you’re a visitor is not the politest,” Walker said while visiting the prestigious Chatham House think tank in London.
He also refused to say whether he believed in evolution. “I’m here to talk about trade, not to pontificate on other issues. I love the evolution of trade in Wisconsin and I’d like to see an even bigger evolution as well,” Walker told BBC journalist Justin Webb.
3. Won’t say if Obama loves America
After Rudy Giuliani, at a private event held for Walker, said he didn’t think President Obama loves America, Walker was asked if he agreed with the former New York mayor — and the governor wouldn’t say one way or the other.
“I’m not going to comment on what the President thinks or not,” Walker said during an interview on CNBC. “He can speak for himself.”
4. Unions are just like ISIS
One of Walker’s biggest challenges was to establish himself as credible on foreign policy. Despite studying intensely with a rotating cast of GOP wonks, he stretched a bit too far during the Conservative Political Action Conference in late February, when he said that fighting union protesters in his home state showed he could defeat the Islamic State.
“If I can take on 100,000 protesters, I can do the same across the world,” Walker said.
5. Firing the air traffic controllers defeated the Soviets
It didn’t take long for Walker to make another foreign policy gaffe. Days later at a Club for Growth cattle call in Palm Beach, Florida, he said the “most significant foreign policy decision of my lifetime” was President Ronald Reagan decision to break an air traffic controllers’ strike in 1981 by firing roughly 11,000 of them.
“It sent a message not only across America, it sent a message around the world,” the Wisconsin governor said.
6. The Wall
In late August, during an interview with NBC’s Chuck Todd, Walker said he had “legitimate concerns” about beefing up border security not just along the border with Mexico but also the Canadian border, saying he’d been asked about that in New Hampshire. Todd asked if Walker would consider building a wall along America’s 4,000-mile northern border — and Walker didn’t laugh it off, as another candidate might have.
“They have raised some very legitimate concerns, including some law enforcement folks that brought that up to me at one of our hall meetings about a week and a half ago. So that’s a legitimate issue for us to look at,” Walker said. He was quickly mocked, and his communications staff had to clean up after him the next day.
7. When ‘yeah’ doesn’t mean ‘yes’
Walker was hounded by questions about birthright citizenship after he was asked in mid-August whether he agreed with Donald Trump that the children of illegal immigrants who were born on American soil should be deported. “Yeah, to me it’s about enforcing the laws in this country,” Walker said — reverting to his verbal tic of saying “yeah” without necessarily meaning agreement. “And I’ve been very clear: I think you enforce the laws, and I think it’s important to send a message that we’re going to enforce the laws, no matter how people come here we’re going to enforce the laws.”
Obviously, no candidate can get through a campaign without saying a few things he or she later wishes he or she had not said. (And in the case of Bernie Sanders, previous statements come up to bite you decades later, such as his interesting views on men and women.) For that matter, in the decades I’ve been calling high school and college games and making various media appearances, there hasn’t been one instance where I didn’t feel afterward I could have something better, at minimum.
Walker’s first supposed gaffe is insignificant. The second was partly insignificant (the part about evolution) and partly dancing when you’re supposed to be there for another reason. The fifth was clearly incorrect (hint: Iceland), and the sixth and seventh were non-answers that were the wrong answer. The others should have been answered better than they were.
So, Mr. Former PR Guy, how would you have answered the questions? Glad you asked! To channel my inner Lyn Nofziger and try to imagine what Walker meant to say instead of what he said (or for that matter what I believe):
2. While his statement about “the evolution of trade in Wisconsin” was a reasonably clever verbal turn, he could have talked about how he believes in better relations with our historic allies such as Great Britain, both economically and militarily, and that the Obama administration has made things worse with our allies and not better with our enemies. (You know, Iran.)
3. Walker could have said that no one who wants to “fundamentally change America” to make America weaker loves America. Voters want the candidates to make things better, not different.
4. The comparison of ISIS to the union thugs could have been answered by asking which other presidential candidate dealt with political opponents who damaged historic state property and threatened the lives of the candidate and his or her family. Or, for that matter, which other presidential candidate survived a recall attempt (that was thoroughly illegitimate).
5. It wasn’t the air traffic controllers, it was Reagan’s walking away from the Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty talks with the Soviet Union’s Mikhail Gorbachev in Reykjavik, Iceland, which in turn was the manifestation of Reagan’s four-word policy statement on how to deal with the Soviets: “We win, they lose.”
6. Are Canadians illegally flooding into the U.S.? Obviously not, but “They have raised some very legitimate concerns, including some law enforcement folks that brought that up to me at one of our hall meetings about a week and a half ago.” That issue needs to be viewed as a security question, not an immigration question. (Another dimension to add is the reason people illegally enter the U.S. — because they think it’s better here than where they are — so the answer to illegal immigration is not walls, but improving the economies of Mexico and elsewhere.)
7. See the last sentence of number 6.
Given the degree with which Walker has always been composed and prepared when speaking to Wisconsin media during his political career, either he didn’t sufficiently prepare, or his media handlers didn’t sufficiently prepare him, or the media game requires considerably better performance at the national level.
Right Wisconsin’s Savvy Pundit has his own list of not gaffes, but reasons Walker’s campaign ended before a single vote was cast:
1. Too Much Too Soon – The Walker campaign went supernova a lot earlier than anyone expected. On one hand that made Governor Walker a font runner, attracted cash, attracted attention and was a very good thing. On the other hand, however, if forced the Walker campaign to build out a large, national campaign sized staff and a national campaign travel footprint early rather than slowly building out from Iowa. Big staffs cost big money. Having to go national early strained Walker’s resources in the long run and made his campaign less sustainable when donors began to get cold feet in the past weeks. Walker’s surprisingly fast ascendency also thrust him into commenting on topics before he was ready. Walker had almost no low stakes ramp up period to test out messages and to get his legs under him in terms of dealing with national and international issues under intense national media scrutiny. He never got to work out the clinkers off Broadway before hitting the main stage. That led to several self-inflicted rhetorical wounds that made people question if he was really ready for prime time.2. He Got Trumped – The Donald Trump phenomenon is the central story in this year’s GOP campaign so far. He has sucked the oxygen out of the room for everyone in the GOP field. Perhaps Walker’s biggest campaign mistake was panicking after Trump stole the show in the first GOP debate. In response to criticism that he was too passive during the debate, Walker started commenting on everything and responding to issues that were not in his wheelhouse. He looked and sounded like he was flailing around and the decline in his poll numbers can be traced most directly to this period directly following the debate. He started playing Trump’s game instead of his own with disastrous effect. Trump could make outrageous statements about border walls and the like and not pay a political price because deep down everyone expects him to be an entertaining buffoon. When Walker made similar slips, he nosedived because his campaign was based on his governing competence and anything that cast doubt on that competence cast doubt on his legitimacy as a candidate.3. Loss of Focus – Governor Walker’s strongest trait throughout his political career has been his message discipline. He knows who he is, he knows the issues he wants to focus on, and he sticks to them with an uncanny tenacity. In the Legislature it was criminal justice, at the County it was taxes, at the state it was Act 10. At each stop critics mocked him as a “one trick pony” but they missed the fact that the ponies he picked ran like Secretariat. The most confounding thing about the Walker presidential campaign was how he seemed to lose his trademark message discipline. He allowed himself to be drawn into every issue of the day rather than deftly redirecting back to his own issues with an, “I know some candidates are focusing on that, but my campaign is about …..” Instead of being extremely deep and well-messaged on a narrow band of issues, he made himself appear a mile wide and an inch deep, responding to every issue that popped up. By trying so hard to prove he belonged on the national stage he lost his unique focus that brought him to the national stage. When he tried to get back to “his issues” by announcing plans to attack federal unions, he looked as silly and desperate as aging rockers repackaging acoustic versions of their greatest hits in order to make a few bucks.4. Be Who You Are – Throughout the campaign Walker never seemed to find a comfortable balance between who he is and who he wanted to be. That discomfort was perceived by the voters and over time made him seem less than authentic. He seemed to crave the image of a national big shot – traveling to foreign countries, courting the elite, and being a big league politician. That image, however, contrasted with the “kid from Janesville” and “outsider” image he also tried to push in a crowded field featuring some high profile outsiders. Scott Walker is a “career politician,” but Scott Walker is not an establishment politician. Scott Walker has made a career of challenging the establishment and taking on the status quo. He never seemed to realize just how unique he was. Even as a career politician Scott Walker was dramatically different from the other candidates in the GOP field. The Kohl’s sweater story was great and all, but why not ask all the other candidates on the stage, “How many of you are still paying a mortgage?” “How many of you have credit card debt?” “How many of you are taking out loans to put your kids through college?” “How many of you left college early because life intervened and you needed to get a job?” In the entire GOP field, that image was one unique to Scott Walker and, ironically, common to most American voters. The Walker campaign had a unique opportunity to convince ordinary Americans he cared about the challenges they faced because – unlike every other candidate in the field – he actually faced them too. It was a politically exploitable difference with the rest of the field that would have made Walker come across as a more authentic and empathetic candidate. Unfortunately, it was a difference his campaign never embraced.5. Dance With the Girl Who Brung You – I hate criticizing campaign managers. It’s a very tough job. The campaign manager always gets the blame for a loss while the candidate gets all the credit for a win. That being said, Rick Wiley was miscast as the Walker for President campaign manager. Wiley is a very good strategist and manager, but he does not speak “Walkereese.” While it is true that Scott Walker is his own primary (some would say sole) political advisor, it is also true that over the years there are a handful of individuals who know his language and his style to the point where they can nudge and steer him in a way that Wiley never could. Those people should have been in charge of the campaign. Perhaps Scott Walker the candidate’s biggest mistake was to put a day-to-day national campaign team together that was not instinctively in sync with what makes Scott Walker Scott Walker, how to keep Scott Walker Scott Walker, and how to introduce a national audience to an authentic Scott Walker.The 70 Days of Walker were an incredible ride that ended too soon. Scott Walker is a skilled, passionate and thoroughly decent man who would have made an outstanding president…but, like all but one citizen of this country, he won’t get there this election.