“I have a very bad feeling about this.”

The headline is from “Star Wars: A New Hope,” not “Raiders of the Lost Ark,” and it was spoken by Luke Skywalker, not Han Solo.

So I’m mixing my movie references for this item about “Raiders,” starring Ripon College almost-graduate Harrison Ford, as worried about by Jim Geraghty:

This is a bad idea, in its current form. But it doesn’t have to be.

Our ever reliable sources are informing us that while Harrison Ford might still play Indiana Jones in the next film of the franchise, the window of making that happen is getting smaller and smaller.

There is a date and if Indiana Jones 5 is not moving forward by then, the studios are 100% prepared to recast a younger Dr. Jones and ready up a new trilogy.

Let’s be realistic, Harrison is not the box office draw he once was and he is only getting older.

Don’t think of it as a reboot but just recasting the same way the James Bond (Sean Connery, Roger Moore, Pierce Brosnan, Daniel Craig) movies have been doing for the better part of five decades.

And who just might be one of the actors that the studio is looking at ? The word is that they are looking at several but Bradley Cooper is at the top of the list.

Like I said, as is, this is a terrible idea. We’ve actually had four actors play Indiana Jones besides Harrison Ford — River Phoenix as Young Indy in the beginning of Last Crusade and then Corey Carrier, Sean Patrick Flanery, and George Hall in The Young Indiana Jones Chronicles. But when you say, “Indiana Jones,” everyone thinks of Harrison Ford. He owns the role. It’s his. Leave it to him.

There’s no need to rehash the criticisms of Indiana Jones and the Crystal Skull; needless to say, most of the fan base left deeply disappointed, and has likely concluded that it doesn’t want, or need, any more Indiana Jones movies. But we sure as heck would love to see more movies in the tone and style of Raiders of the Lost Ark.

So allow me to offer Disney two possibilities.

Option One: Tell a 1930s–1940s–1950s pulp adventure story featuring another adventurer, perhaps someone who’s heard of Indiana Jones or mentions him as a rival. (In Raiders, Indy himself mentions he has rivals going after the same treasures he does: “This is where Forrestal cashed in… He was good. Very good.”) A lot of real-life archeologists are mentioned as “the real life Indiana Jones” or claimed to be the inspiration for Indiana Jones —Roy Chapman AndrewsHiram BinghamPercy FawcettHoward CarterFrederick Mitchell-Hedges, among others. Alternatively, let Cooper play one of Professor Jones’s first students, determined to emulate Indy. Maybe even bring in Ford for a cameo; maybe this student is looking for the one treasure Indy never found. Make clear this is a story that’s taking place in the world of Indiana Jones, but that Indy is enjoying retirement with Marion.

Option Two: The other possibility — one I prefer — is to tell a story that takes place in the modern day. Cooper could be a descendant of Indy’s, or just some young archeologist who’s uncovered Indy’s personal papers (his own “grail diary?”). Maybe today’s archeologists dismiss Jones as a bit of a lunatic and reckless daredevil. (See Professor Jones Gets Rejected for Tenure.) But our protagonist — a bit of a stand-in for the audience — thinks Indy is the coolest guy that ever lived and is determined to follow in his footsteps.

Like in the other scenario, he finds a reference to some long-lost treasure that Indy sought but could never locate … and of course, a key missing clue has only now been found at some recent archeological discoverythe gold at the Temple Mount, the Egyptian city buried under the Mediterranean Sea, even the ship found underground at the site of the World Trade Center.

Like Indy, our Bradley Cooper character begins with a bit of a mercenary side to him, chasing fortune and glory — maybe even talking aloud to his unseen late mentor, “I hope you’re watching from up there, Indy, ‘cause I’m gonna do what you never could!” — but gradually learns to be a more well-rounded person, caring for others, and learning there’s more to life than just treasure and punching people.

You can still tell a pulp-style Indiana Jones story in today’s world; our globe still has enough far-off dangerous and exotic corners — the mountains of central Asia, the pirate-laden waters of Southeast Asia and the horn of Africa, the jungles of the Amazon, just about anywhere in the Middle East … Just remember to include femme fatales and feisty companions, comical sidekicks, villains that you love to hate, constant fistfights, gunfights, chases, and at least once, a menace of a lot of dangerous animals in a confined space — perhaps the saltwater crocodiles of Ramree Island, Burma. …

Most importantly — and perhaps the element that makes Bradley Cooper the right guy to carry the torch — any new films need to remember to include the two key moments of every Indiana Jones sequence:


Our hero suddenly realizes he’s bitten off more than he can chew, eyes bulge, and we share with him a split-second of panic or “oh, crap”

This is what I look like when I’m on cable news and realize the show changed topics without telling me.


Our hero smiles.

This is what I look like when I’ve steered the topic back to the one-liner I wanted to use.

You’re welcome, Disney.

I’m not a reflexive hater of remakes, though most of them shouldn’t have been remade, particularly the movies made from ’60s and ’70s and ’80s TV series. I’m a huge fan of the original “Star Trek” and “Hawaii Five-O,” but I can tolerate their remakes.

The “Raiders” franchise isn’t a remake itself exactly. It is a throwback to the adventure serials and melodramas of the 1930s and 1940s, a movie form that had been forgotten until George Lucas and Steven Spielberg teamed up on “Raiders.” You can tell how successful an idea is by the number of imitators it spawns, such as Tom Selleck (the original choice for Jones, though Selleck was “Magnum, P.I.”) in “High Road to China,” Richard Chamberlain in “King Solomon’s Mines” (which was both a remake and a, shall we say, inspired ripoff), and “The Mummy” movies with Brendan Fraser.

The problem with most remakes, however, is that it’s impossible to recapture what made the franchise iconic in the first place — how the actors played their roles. Some series set in a particular time are unable to transition to contemporary times — “The Avengers” (Patrick Macnee, not the other one) and “Starsky and Hutch” come to mind, along with possibly James Bond, though interestingly that has survived six different James Bonds. (Imagine the challenge of trying to remake a ’50s or ’60s TV detective series, such as “Peter Gunn” or “Mannix.” Or, for that matter, a “Magnum” movie, which has been proposed.) Setting is not an issue with the “Raiders” franchise, since it’s set in the past.

The surmounting issue is who can play Indiana Jones, assuming Ford is too old to play Indiana Jones. (Even though, as you know, it’s not the years, it’s the mileage.) It takes a particular kind of actor to be credible to the moviegoer while veering from one deadly scenario to the next in the space of a few minutes. In different settings, John Wayne was utterly believable in every Western he ever acted in, and Charlton Heston brought believability to the science fiction movies he was cast in, from “Planet of the Apes” to “The Omega Man” to “Soylent Green.” That’s what casting Shia LeBoeuf in the fourth Indiana Jones movie was supposed to do, but apparently he failed, since he’s not being mentioned in Indiana Jones V.

Fans of a particular franchise inevitably judge the remake on the original, even prequels, and the remake usually loses in the comparison. Really: What other actor could do this?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s